# M02 sample quality review

## Core tests
Today: A D2C merchandiser who can edit this PDP can replace the ambiguous inclusion summary, preserve the fit qualification and flag the conflicting iron setting using delivered blocks.
Absence: The facts are publicly searchable; the added value is this exact cross-source discrepancy, variant exception mapping, paste-ready changes and reversible placement handoff, not exclusive product knowledge.

## Pass 1, actual initial review
G1 3, G2 2, G3 3, G4 2, G5 1, G6 3, G7 2 = 16/21, FAIL. The first saved draft discarded the 12–16-inch best-fit range and repeated warm-iron guidance without acknowledging the official care guide's low setting. This was an internal editorial review, not independent brand validation.

## Revision performed
Saved review-draft-v1.md before modifying the proposal. Restored the best-fit qualifier, added the explicit source conflict and made owner resolution a publication gate. See revision.diff and revision-log.md.

## Pass 2, revised deliverable
G1 3, G2 2, G3 3, G4 2, G5 3, G6 3, G7 2 = 18/21, PASS for file-delivery usefulness only. Novelty is limited to three concrete observations on one named PDP: summary/detail pillowcase mismatch, best-fit qualification, cross-source ironing discrepancy. Reproducibility is bounded because browser capture was unreliable and variant-switch behavior was not tested. Nonpromotion gets 2 because this is necessarily a product-copy demonstration, not independent consumer advice. No fabricated independent reviewer.

## Expertise and format
L1: actual live PDP snapshot with Details opened. L2: repeatable source and variant QA checklist. L3: named one-page teardown. L4: preserved initial editorial error and actual revision. External-article two-publication format review is not applicable to this one-PDP file scope. Minimal standalone preview is provided; it does not reproduce Brooklinen's theme.

## Tests and limits
- Exact JSON keys and observation fields checked by generation assertions
- Every delivery href maps to a nonempty file
- Excerpt SHA-256 hashes and captured-file hashes generated locally
- Unified excerpt-to-proposal diff and actual revision diff generated
- Current live PDP rendered accessibility tree inspected; screenshot failed with CDP timeout
- Care guide webfetch succeeded; browser snapshot timed out
- Local visual preview, mobile/desktop screenshots, theme insertion and browser accessibility audit remain unverified
- No claimed uplift, permission, endorsement, live edit, CMS success, customer revision or measured ranking

These scores are self-assessment, not an external certification or a production-release pass.